• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Markets
  • Trade Ideas
  • Reflections
  • Links
  • Trading Program
    • Spec Model Trading Manual
    • Spec Model Trades
    • Spec Model Positions
  • Income Model
    • Income Model Trading Manual
    • Income Model Trades
    • Income Model Positions
  • Watch List
    • Watch List: Spec Long Plays
    • Watch List: Spec Short Plays
    • Watch List: Income Plays
  • About
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Service
    • Terms of Participation

Zach Scheidt

Helping families build wealth so they can focus on what really matters

Investment Income Part II: Finding the Best Income Plays

October 31, 2021 at 5:32 pm by Zach Scheidt

Income Play

[Editor’s Note: This is part II of our series on investment income plays selling put contracts. In Part I I explained put contracts and how to sell them for income.

Today, we’ll cover how to pick the right stocks and which put contracts to use with this strategy.]


In part I of this series I explained how the put-selling process works.

  • We covered what a put contract IS (an agreement between traders)…
  • How selling a contract is the same as entering an agreement…
  • That you get paid when you enter one of these contracts…
  • The potential that you may be required to buy shares of stock…
  • How your brokerage account sets aside cash until the position is closed…
  • That each put contract has an expiration date…
  • And the three possible outcomes for each income trade…

It was a lot to cover I know. And you may still have questions! Please feel free to comment below or send me an email with your specific questions. Remember, I can’t give individual investment advice. But I CAN use your question to clarify the process for everyone here.

Once you understand how the process works, you still have some decisions to make.

Like which stocks to use and then which specific put contracts are best to sell.

We’ll cover those decisions today before moving on to some of the great advantages of this approach in the next few installments.

The Best Stocks for Income Plays

When searching for the best income plays to use with this strategy, I always start with a watch list of stocks I would like to own. In other words, I only use this strategy for stocks I am confident will trade higher.

It’s a good idea to always have a watch list of companies that you’re following. That way, when it’s time to set up a new income play, you’ve already got a list of great candidates you’ve been researching. (Here’s a link to sign up for a free copy of my current watch list.)

I like to set up income plays when one of my favorite watch list stocks trades with a particular chart pattern. This helps improve the likelihood that the stock will move higher in the near future. Some of these patterns include:

  • Cup with handle — I wrote about this pattern here.
  • Pullback to support
  • Double bottom
  • Breakout above resistance
  • Oversold rebound

We’ll talk more about these setups in the future. The key is to pick stocks you would want to invest in, and to set up your income play at a time when the stock is most likely to trade higher.

Pay special attention to which industries are in play.

For instance, if the market is facing a high level of inflation, you may want to consider bank stocks, gold miners or producers of tangible items like oil and construction materials.

And when other investors are confident and the market is moving steadily higher, tech stocks can be great candidates for our income plays.

Once you have a stock picked out, the next step is to look at which put contract to sell.

Picking the Right Put Contract

For every active stock traded on U.S. exchanges there are dozens of put contracts to pick from. How do you know which contract to sell?

I have two requirements for my income plays:

  • They must be out of the money…
  • And they must expire in the near future.

A put contract is “out of the money” if the strike price is below the stock’s current market price.

For example, Schlumberger (SLB) recently closed at $32.24. You could sell a $30 put contract which is “out of the money”

Selling this put contract gives someone the right to sell SLB to you at $30. Since the stock is trading at $32.24, the buyer wouldn’t want to exercise his “right” today. After all, they could get more money by selling at the market price.

So the $30 put contract is considered “out of the money” because $30 is below the current market price for SLB.

Selling a put contract that expires in the near future also works to your advantage. I usually sell put contracts that expire between 3 and 8 weeks in the future.

As we get closer to the expiration date, the value of a put contract decreases. This is known as “time decay.”

Think about it this way… You would pay less for an insurance policy that only protected you for a couple weeks. The same holds for the price traders will pay for put contracts.

The closer the expiration date, the faster the value for put contracts deteriorate. Since we sell put contracts to collect income, faster time decay works in our favor.

Eventually we want our put contract to expire (and disappear from our account), or we’d like to buy it back at a lower price. Either way, faster the time decay grows our profits more quickly.

Measuring Our Income Play Ahead of the Trade

To pick the best income plays for our put-selling strategy, you need to be able to calculate the annualized rate of return for selling a put contract.

Remember, selling a put contract is the same as agreeing to buy shares of stock. And your broker will set aside the cash (or margin buying power) in case you’re required to buy those shares.

A wise investor will ask “What am I paid for setting this cash aside?”

You should make sure the put contract pays you an attractive amount of income for the money you’re setting aside. And you must also consider the time until expiration.

I use a simple spreadsheet to calculate the rate of return for my income plays.

The left side shows the table which calculates a 44.87% annualized rate of return for a specific put contract. And for you excel nerds (like me), I’ve included a table that shows the calculations for each cell. This way you can recreate the table yourself!

Let’s look at the put contract in the example table above:

  • The price is $5.20 for selling the put contract.
  • The put contract has a $90 strike price.
  • Our contract expires in 47days.
  • We must set aside $9,000 for this income play.
  • We receive $520 from selling the contracts.
  • That $520 represents a 5.78% rate of return.
  • The annualized rate of return is 44.87%.

So if we could continually make trades like this with all of our capital throughout the entire year, our account value would grow by 44.87%.

Balancing Risk and Reward

When you calculate the return for different put contracts, you’ll notice some big differences in annualized rates of return. Here are some concepts to help explain (and to help you pick the best contracts).

  • The closer the put’s strike price to the actual market price, the more income.
  • But keep in mind, this means there’s probably a higher chance the stock could trade below that level.
  • The more volatile a stock’s expected price movement, the more income you’ll receive.
  • There’s an art to picking plays volatile enough for good income, but plays that are not too risky.

It’s not reasonable to expect every trade to work out perfectly. Some plays lose money. Others may be closed out for smaller gains.

There are also situations where a trade can be closed out early and lock in a higher annualized rate of return.

In the next installment, we’ll discuss putting together a portfolio of income plays. We’ll talk about strategies for getting the max value for each income play. And most importantly, we’ll see how much money you can really make with this strategy.

Sign up to get the next installment in your inbox here!

(Trade procedure: 5 minutes after this notification posts, I will enter the trade on my brokerage platform. Once filled I will edit this post to include execution prices.)

Please note: I am placing these trades in my own account. And while I notify the group of all trades 5 minutes before I place my own personal trades, this creates a conflict of interest. Please review all disclosures and agreements included with your subscription packet.

Filed Under: Education, Public Tagged With: income plays, Investment income, investor education, Options, put selling

Primary Sidebar

Get your FREE copy of my watch list




You’ll also receive my (almost) daily market insights — you can cancel at any time.

stock market is bad

The Stock Market is So Bad, It’s GREAT!

I’m kicking myself for not being better prepared. The stock market is so bad, it’s primed for a big-time rally!

gold rally

Time for Gold to Rally!

The gold rally has been held back by two important factors. But now that these two challenges are going away, gold could surge!

share buybacks

Terrible Timing to Stop Share Buybacks

A bear market is a terrible time to stop share buybacks. But some companies are using this opportunity to build shareholder value!

official bear market

What I’m Watching as an Official Bear Market Looms

Stocks are just a couple percentage points away from official bear market territory. Here’s how I’m positioned heading into next week.

Hated homebuilder stocks

I’m Bullish on Hated Homebuilder Stocks

Shares of hated homebuilder stocks are lower this year. But this area offers tremendous value that could lead to gains this summer!

stock market new season

Can the Stock Market Shift to a New Season?

After seven straight weeks of losses, the stock market may be shifting to a new season. Here’s why I’m optimistic about the week ahead.

good stocks fall

Why Good Stocks Fall

Good stocks fall when investors need cash (and have no options left). That’s good news and points to a rebound in sight!

value stocks outperform

April was Brutal — But There Are Still Winning Stocks

Stocks fell in April — booking the worst month for the Nasdaq since the dot-com crisis. But despite the carnage value stocks outperformed

Stock Market Indicator

This Stock Market Indicator Points to a Bounce

There’s a lot of fear in today’s market. But despite the selling, one stock market indicator is signaling a bounce!

Three reasons to buy Meta

Three Reasons to Buy Meta Ahead of Earnings

Facebook’s parent Meta Platforms is scheduled to release earnings this week. Here are three reasons I chose to buy Meta ahead of the report.

Investors are buying stock insurance

Investors Buying “Stock Insurance” – Here’s How to Profit

The price for “stock insurance” — or put contracts that protect investors’ wealth — is rising. Here’s how to use that to your advantage!

Barbell Approach

For Stronger Investment Returns, Use THIS Barbell

Splitting your investment account into a “safe” portion and more “aggressive” positions can help to manage risk and improve returns.

This Market is FULL of Great Investment Plays

There is no shortage of opportunity in today’s market. But you have to know where to look for the best investment plays.

Quarterly Trading Update

Quarterly Trading Update — March 2022

Now that the first quarter is over, I wanted to share an update on how our trading models performed.

gold investors

Three Options for Gold Investors

As precious metal prices rise gold investors have quite a few options. Here are three ways to profit from higher gold and silver.

DISCLAIMER: Stocks and options trading have large potential rewards, but also large potential risk. You must be aware of the risks and be willing to accept them in order to invest in the stocks and options markets. Don't trade with money you can't afford to lose.

This is neither a solicitation nor an offer to Buy/Sell stocks or options. No representation is being made that any account will or is likely to achieve profits or losses similar to those discussed on this page. The past performance of any trading system or methodology is not necessarily indicative of future results.

All trades, patterns, charts, systems, etc., discussed on this page are for illustrative purposes only and not to be construed as specific advisory recommendations. Information contained on this site or in any correspondence is intended for informational purposes only and was obtained from sources believed to be reliable. Information is in no way guaranteed. No guarantee of any kind is implied or possible where projections of future conditions are attempted.

Arete Publishing, LLC · Copyright © 2022 · All Rights Reserved
Privacy Policy · Terms of Service · Terms of Participation · Log in