• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Markets
  • Trade Ideas
  • Reflections
  • Links
  • Trading Program
    • Spec Model Trading Manual
    • Spec Model Trades
    • Spec Model Positions
  • Income Model
    • Income Model Trading Manual
    • Income Model Trades
    • Income Model Positions
  • Watch List
    • Watch List: Spec Long Plays
    • Watch List: Spec Short Plays
    • Watch List: Income Plays
  • About
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Service
    • Terms of Participation

Zach Scheidt

Helping families build wealth so they can focus on what really matters

Investment Income Part V: There’s Always a Catch…

November 6, 2021 at 9:25 pm by Zach Scheidt

There's always a catch

[Editor’s Note: This is part V of our series on investment income plays selling put contracts.

  • In Part I we talked about put contracts and how to sell them for income.
  • Part II covered how to find the best income plays.
  • In Part III we covered how much income you can really make.
  • And in Part IV we talked about how this strategy holds up in a bear market.

Today, I want to explain “the catch” behind this strategy. In other words, we’ll cover what you’re giving up to book reliable income from this strategy.]


“There’s no such thing as a free lunch…“

At least that’s what my mom told us as kids. (Typically the statement came right before she pulled out her list of chores for us.)

The statement is usually true with your investments as well. There’s no “free money” in the market. And for the most part, when you hear about strategy or approach that has a special advantage, there’s always a catch.

Even our income strategy that I love so much comes with a price.

Once you understand what you have to give up to collect our income payments, you might decide this strategy isn’t for you.

Or you may agree with me… (I think the income we get from this approach is well worth the price of admission.)

Either way, I want to make sure you’re fully informed before you decide to use this income approach in your own account.

Playing “A-B-C” Baseball

To understand the “catch” behind this income strategy, it helps to use a baseball analogy.

There are baseball teams known for their power hitters. And fans love to go to the ballpark and watch these hitters knock the long-ball out of the park.

On the other end of the spectrum, teams that play “A-B-C” baseball start by getting a runner on base. Then, the next hitter may sacrifice to move him over to second or third base. These teams “manufacture” runs by doing small things right and putting probabilities in their favor.

Power teams win huge games in dramatic fashion when the big hitters connect.

But fundamental teams consistently score runs and usually wind up with a chance to make the playoffs at the end of a season.

As you might have guessed, our income strategy is a lot like the fundamental baseball team.

When you sell a put contract, you’re stepping up to the plate and trying to hit a single or a double. The most you can possibly make is the income you receive from selling your put contract.

So you’re never going to shoot the lights out with any single trade.

Let’s take a look at a recent example.

Always a Catch: MARA Example

Last month I used our income strategy to collect a payment from shares of Marathon Digital (MARA). The company is a cryptocurrency miner and with Bitcoin moving back towards all-time highs, the company’s outlook was strong. Plus, the stock bounced off a key support line (see chart below).

The chart above shows what MARA looked like on October 6th. On that day I sold two MARA put contracts. These contracts had a November 19th expiration date and a $35 strike price. So by selling these shares, I was agreeing to buy MARA at $35 — and my agreement was set to last until November 19th.

I received $3.43 per share for entering this agreement. So with two contracts (each representing 100 shares) my total income was $686 (less commissions).

Given the strong backdrop for the company (with Bitcoin prices rising) I would have been happy to buy shares of MARA at $35. And I was pleased with the $686 of income I received from this trade.

Now, let’s take a look at where MARA stands today…

Always a catch -- missing out on MARA profits

As you can see, shares of MARA surged higher. Anyone who bought shares of MARA on the day I sold my put contracts could have ultimately made about $25 per share.

I ultimately closed out my trade, buying the puts back at $0.70 and locking in a gain of $2.73 per share — or about $545 for the two contracts. And while I was happy with the income, I didn’t hit a “home run” with MARA.

Balancing Reliability And Big Wins

So is this income approach the BEST way to invest? Or is it better to swing for the fences and lock in bigger profits?

I don’t think there’s necessarily a right or a wrong answer here. And you don’t necessarily have to choose between the two!

(I actually keep an account that I use for aggressive / speculative trades, and another account that I use for generating income with my favorite put-selling approach).

The important take-away from today’s message is that there’s always a catch when it comes to different strategies. You have to give up one thing in order to get something else.

In this case, our income strategy is reliable and can cut down on your investment risk. But it also gives up the potential for much bigger profits if your stock shoots higher.

Understanding the whole picture — including both the advantages and disadvantages — gives you a chance to make an informed decision about whether this approach is right for you.

We’ll keep covering more details about this approach and how to use it in your own brokerage account.

In the meantime, please let me know if you have questions! You can leave a comment below and I’ll do my best to clarify anything I need to in future alerts.

Here’s to generating reliable income from your favorite stocks!

(Trade procedure: 5 minutes after this notification posts, I will enter the trade on my brokerage platform. Once filled I will edit this post to include execution prices.)

Please note: I am placing these trades in my own account. And while I notify the group of all trades 5 minutes before I place my own personal trades, this creates a conflict of interest. Please review all disclosures and agreements included with your subscription packet.

Filed Under: Education, Public Tagged With: Investment income, investor education, put selling

Primary Sidebar

Get your FREE copy of my watch list




You’ll also receive my (almost) daily market insights — you can cancel at any time.

stock market is bad

The Stock Market is So Bad, It’s GREAT!

I’m kicking myself for not being better prepared. The stock market is so bad, it’s primed for a big-time rally!

gold rally

Time for Gold to Rally!

The gold rally has been held back by two important factors. But now that these two challenges are going away, gold could surge!

share buybacks

Terrible Timing to Stop Share Buybacks

A bear market is a terrible time to stop share buybacks. But some companies are using this opportunity to build shareholder value!

official bear market

What I’m Watching as an Official Bear Market Looms

Stocks are just a couple percentage points away from official bear market territory. Here’s how I’m positioned heading into next week.

Hated homebuilder stocks

I’m Bullish on Hated Homebuilder Stocks

Shares of hated homebuilder stocks are lower this year. But this area offers tremendous value that could lead to gains this summer!

stock market new season

Can the Stock Market Shift to a New Season?

After seven straight weeks of losses, the stock market may be shifting to a new season. Here’s why I’m optimistic about the week ahead.

good stocks fall

Why Good Stocks Fall

Good stocks fall when investors need cash (and have no options left). That’s good news and points to a rebound in sight!

value stocks outperform

April was Brutal — But There Are Still Winning Stocks

Stocks fell in April — booking the worst month for the Nasdaq since the dot-com crisis. But despite the carnage value stocks outperformed

Stock Market Indicator

This Stock Market Indicator Points to a Bounce

There’s a lot of fear in today’s market. But despite the selling, one stock market indicator is signaling a bounce!

Three reasons to buy Meta

Three Reasons to Buy Meta Ahead of Earnings

Facebook’s parent Meta Platforms is scheduled to release earnings this week. Here are three reasons I chose to buy Meta ahead of the report.

Investors are buying stock insurance

Investors Buying “Stock Insurance” – Here’s How to Profit

The price for “stock insurance” — or put contracts that protect investors’ wealth — is rising. Here’s how to use that to your advantage!

Barbell Approach

For Stronger Investment Returns, Use THIS Barbell

Splitting your investment account into a “safe” portion and more “aggressive” positions can help to manage risk and improve returns.

This Market is FULL of Great Investment Plays

There is no shortage of opportunity in today’s market. But you have to know where to look for the best investment plays.

Quarterly Trading Update

Quarterly Trading Update — March 2022

Now that the first quarter is over, I wanted to share an update on how our trading models performed.

gold investors

Three Options for Gold Investors

As precious metal prices rise gold investors have quite a few options. Here are three ways to profit from higher gold and silver.

DISCLAIMER: Stocks and options trading have large potential rewards, but also large potential risk. You must be aware of the risks and be willing to accept them in order to invest in the stocks and options markets. Don't trade with money you can't afford to lose.

This is neither a solicitation nor an offer to Buy/Sell stocks or options. No representation is being made that any account will or is likely to achieve profits or losses similar to those discussed on this page. The past performance of any trading system or methodology is not necessarily indicative of future results.

All trades, patterns, charts, systems, etc., discussed on this page are for illustrative purposes only and not to be construed as specific advisory recommendations. Information contained on this site or in any correspondence is intended for informational purposes only and was obtained from sources believed to be reliable. Information is in no way guaranteed. No guarantee of any kind is implied or possible where projections of future conditions are attempted.

Arete Publishing, LLC · Copyright © 2022 · All Rights Reserved
Privacy Policy · Terms of Service · Terms of Participation · Log in